The 50/50 Lie
When two co-founders start a company, the default conversation usually goes like this:
"We're partners. 50/50?" "Deal."
This is the first mistake. It feels "fair" emotionally, but it is incorrect mathematically.
Why 50/50 Fails
Equity is not a reward for friendship. It is a reward for risk and execution. A 50/50 split implies a perfectly symmetrical future:
- Both founders will take identical risk.
- Both founders will add identical value.
- Neither founder's life circumstances will change.
This is a statistical impossibility.
The Alternative: Dynamic Splits
Instead of a static snapshot, view equity as a dynamic ledger. The "Slicing Pie" model (invented by Mike Moyer) suggests allocating equity based on the fair market value of contributions.
If Founder A puts in $50k cash and Founder B puts in $0 but works full-time:
- Cash is liquid and high risk.
- Labor is illiquid but high value.
You need a multiplier. Typically, cash gets a 4x multiplier (because it's scarce) and unpaid labor gets a 2x multiplier.
Dead Equity and The Cliff
The bigger danger than the split itself is Dead Equity. This happens when a co-founder leaves with a large chunk of the cap table, rendering the company uninvestable.
The standard solution is Vesting with a Cliff:
- 4 Year Vesting: You earn your shares over 48 months.
- 1 Year Cliff: If you leave before month 12, you get 0%.
This isn't just legalese; it's a mechanism to filter for commitment.
The Dilution Trap
Founders often obsess over their percentage ownership rather than the value of the underlying asset.
Use our Equity Calculator to run this scenario:
- You own 50% of a $2M company. Value = $1M.
- You raise money and own 30% of a $10M company. Value = $3M.
You own less of the company, but you are richer. This is the only math that matters.
If you are optimizing for control (percentage), you are building a lifestyle business. If you are optimizing for outcome (value), you must welcome dilution as the cost of growth.
Calculating Your True Worth
Don't just look at the gross value of your shares. You must calculate the Net Value:
Net Value = (Share Price * Shares) - (Strike Price * Shares) - Taxes
Many employees at "unicorns" realize too late that their high strike price + taxes makes their options worthless, even at a high valuation.
Check the math yourself on the Equity Calculator. Don't trust the offer letter's "potential value." Trust the numbers.